The Valebridge Mill Pond petition has 599 signatures after its organiser met Cllr Simon Hicks on 14 November. Next: Environment Agency reports and silt checks.

A petition to bring back Valebridge Mill Pond, beside Bedelands Nature Reserve in Burgess Hill, has reached 599 signatures, and the man behind it, Mark McDonnell, met Councillor Simon Hicks on Saturday 14 November to talk about what could happen next. They agreed to look into the Environment Agency’s reports on the pond, the history of the surviving mill structures and concerns about silt reaching the stream below it.

Updated 14 November: the outcome of the meeting with Cllr Hicks and the new signature count.

The petition, titled Restore Valebridge Mill Pond in Burgess Hill, went up on Change.org on 18 October and is addressed to Mid Sussex District Council and Heaselands Estate. It is aiming for 1,000 signatures; the page showed 203 of them added in the past week.

Overview

  • What the campaign wants: a permanent open-water pond at Valebridge again, rather than the wetland the site is being left to become.
  • Who owns it: Heaselands Estate, which Mr McDonnell says has raised “significant safety, maintenance and cost concerns”.
  • Where it stands: 599 signatures after a meeting with Cllr Simon Hicks on Saturday 14 November.
  • How to support it: sign or share the petition.

What came out of the meeting with Cllr Hicks

Mr McDonnell met Cllr Hicks on Saturday 14 November and described it to us as “a helpful and constructive meeting”. He said they discussed several possible avenues for further investigation:

  • obtaining the relevant Environment Agency reports;
  • researching the historical significance of the surviving mill structures;
  • working with the Bedelands group to investigate concerns about silt entering the downstream watercourse.

“We recognise that restoring the pond presents challenges, particularly given its private ownership, but we remain committed to gathering the relevant evidence and exploring whether a practical restoration solution is possible,” he said. The petition had 599 signatures after the meeting, which he said showed “that local interest in the future of the pond remains strong”.

Why he started it

Mr McDonnell grew up on the Maple Drive estate and calls his campaign Save Our Mill Pond. Writing to Mid Sussex News, he said:

“I started the Save Our Mill Pond campaign because this historic pond means a great deal to local people. Having grown up on the Maple Drive estate, my own connection with the area goes back nearly 50 years.”

The petition itself is more personal still. “For fifty years, I have cherished my walks in the woods, accompanied by beloved family dogs, each one enthralled by reaching the pristine waters of Valebridge Mill Pond,” he wrote when he launched it.

He describes the pond as “a cornerstone of community life for over 400 years” and argues that “the decision to let this historic site transform into wetland diminishes its role in Burgess Hill’s cultural and natural heritage”. The petition also makes an ecological case: that the open water supports aquatic plants and animals, and that a switch to wetland “could lead to a significant reduction in biodiversity”. Those are the campaign’s claims; the estate’s own reasoning has not been published on the petition page.

The owner’s side, as the campaign puts it

The campaign does not pretend the answer is simple. In his email to us, Mr McDonnell said:

“We recognise that the pond is privately owned by Heaselands Estate and that the Estate has raised significant safety, maintenance and cost concerns. Our aim is to explore whether a realistic way of restoring a permanent open-water feature could be found.”

His latest update to supporters, posted on the morning of 9 November when the count stood at 525, lists the obstacles plainly: “There are challenges ahead, including private ownership, safety, costs and environmental considerations.”

What the campaign has done so far

The petition’s updates set out the steps taken since it launched:

  • 21 October, 200 signatures: Mr McDonnell wrote that he had contacted Mid Sussex District Council, Burgess Hill Town Council and the Environment Agency and was waiting for fuller replies. He posted the questions he wants answered: why the decision was made not to restore the pond, what surveys and assessments were carried out, whether other restoration options were considered, what it would cost to bring the pond back, and whether the community had “a meaningful opportunity to have its say”.
  • 1 November, 327 signatures: the campaign said it had been in touch with Heaselands Estate, the Environment Agency and local councils “exploring whether restoring our historic Mill Pond is still possible”.
  • 9 November, 525 signatures: West Sussex County Council had sent historic mapping information. “This helps us understand the pond’s history, although it does not establish legal protection for the pond,” the update says.

Before the meeting, he wrote that he was “preparing to discuss the campaign with Councillor Simon Hicks on Saturday 14 November, including what support the council may be able to offer and how restoration options could be explored.”

What it means for you

If you walk Bedelands or remember the pond as open water, the campaign wants your name on the petition; its next stated target is 750. Mr McDonnell’s update asks people to “ask someone who remembers or enjoys this special place to sign”.

We will report what the Environment Agency reports and the silt investigation turn up. Heaselands Estate is welcome to set out its position on the pond here too.